123 Sheets vs VitalTax
Side-by-side comparison for Making Tax Digital for Income Tax.
123 Sheets
Excel bridging for sole traders and landlords; £19.75/tax year per taxpayer (ex VAT), advertised as a first-year 50% discount.
123 Sheets is HMRC-recognised bridging software (product ID 3123 on the recognised-software finder) for sole traders and landlords who want to keep records in Excel and submit quarterly updates, the Tax return, and MTD VAT to HMRC without switching accounting systems. The vendor's per-audience pricing pages advertise £19.75/year per taxpayer (ex VAT) as a first-year 50% discount; the standard renewal figure is not stated verbatim on the vendor site. MTD VAT is a separately-priced licence at the same £19.75/year (ex VAT), so a taxpayer needing both MTD ITSA and MTD VAT pays two licences. Coverage per HMRC's finder: Quarterly updates and Tax return / Final Declaration are Ready now for Sole trader, UK property and Foreign property income sources; Partnership income and Capital Gains within the Tax return are listed In development.
Visit 123 SheetsVitalTax
Excel add-in bridging; first quarterly submission free, then paid from £30/yr.
VitalTax is an Excel add-in that submits directly from your spreadsheet. Continued MTD Income Tax filing requires a paid annual licence: £30/yr for one taxpayer (National Insurance number), scaling up to £198/yr for unlimited taxpayers. The first quarterly submission is free as a try-before-you-buy mechanic, not a permanent free tier.
Visit VitalTaxFull feature comparison
| 123 Sheets | VitalTax | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing & compliance | ||
| Price from | £19.75/yr | £30/yr |
| Free tier | – | – |
| HMRC-recognised | ✓ | ✓ |
| Features | ||
| Bank feeds | – | – |
| Mobile app | – | – |
| Receipt scanning | – | – |
| CIS support | – | – |
| Furnished holiday let support | – | – |
| VAT submission | – | – |
| Bridging software | ✓ | ✓ |
| Invoicing | – | – |
| Multiple properties | – | – |
| Accountant access | – | – |
| Best suited to | ||
| Sole Traders | ✓ | – |
| Landlords | ✓ | – |
| Airbnb / Short-let Hosts | – | – |
| CIS Subcontractors | – | – |
| Uber & Gig Drivers | – | – |
| Freelancers | – | – |
| Spreadsheet Users | ✓ | ✓ |
| Simple Affairs | ✓ | ✓ |
| Accountants | – | – |
| VAT-Registered | – | – |
✓ = supported. Based on each provider's published plans; check their site for the latest details.
123 Sheets verdict
A workable choice for a sole trader or landlord already living in Excel who just needs the legal submission step and can accept that the standard renewal price is not published on the vendor site. Head-to-head, suiteSheets is now on HMRC's list at £20/tax year with no auto-renewal, so 123 Sheets no longer clearly wins on price alone.
VitalTax verdict
The move if you live in Excel and want to stay there.