← Back

Best CIS account for MTD: side-by-side comparison

Construction Industry Scheme deductions plus MTD Income Tax is a double-whammy. Here's how the main CIS-friendly accounts compare on price, deduction handling and free routes.

If you're a subcontractor under CIS, your contractor deducts 20% (or 30%) at source. Under MTD you still report your gross trading income quarterly, then claim back overpaid tax via the Final Declaration. Software with built-in CIS handling saves a lot of manual reconciliation, but the cheapest CIS-aware account isn't always the obvious one, and there's a free route most subcontractors miss.

Things to think about

Recommended software

5 providers match this situation. Free options first.

Heads up: some outbound links on this page are affiliate links. We may earn a small commission if you sign up, at no extra cost to you, and our rankings aren't affected by who pays us. Full disclosure.
Free with NatWest / Mettle

FreeAgent

Free if you have a NatWest Group business account, otherwise £19–£33/mo.

FreeHMRC-recognised

FreeAgent is a polished UK-built accounting platform owned by NatWest. It's free if you hold a business current account with NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland or Ulster Bank, or a free Mettle business account, and you make at least one transaction a month. Outside that, it's a paid subscription: £19/mo Sole Trader, £27/mo Partnership / LLP, £33/mo Limited Company (with a 50% first-6-months intro discount active on all three tiers as of 2026-09-30). Pricier than Xero Ignite (£18/mo regular) or QuickFile's free XS tier (up to 200 nominal ledger entries/year, MTD Income Tax filing needs QuickFile's Power User subscription). Strong for sole traders, freelancers and landlords wanting guided workflows and built-in project profitability.

bank feedsmobile appreceipt scanninginvoicing
Free bookkeeping plan

Crunch

Accounting software with optional bundled accountant; software-only from £0 (bookkeeping tier with optional MTD VAT and SA add-ons) to £10+VAT/mo, accountancy bundles from £27+VAT/mo.

From £10/moHMRC-recognised

Crunch is UK-built accounting software with an optional bundled-accountant tier, aimed at freelancers, contractors and small UK businesses. Per Crunch's own software-pricing page: Crunch Free (£0) is bookkeeping-only and does not bundle MTD filing, but offers the same optional add-ons as Lite: MTD VAT filing at £5+VAT/mo and Self Assessment filing at £180+VAT one-off. Crunch Lite (£4/mo) adds ad-free workflow with those same add-ons available; MTD Income Tax is not on either. Crunch Plus (£10+VAT/mo) bundles MTD VAT filing and MTD Income Tax return filing. Accountancy bundles (Sole Trader Pro, Limited Company Pro / Premium) start from £27+VAT/mo per the /making-tax-digital-mtd page and are quote-based via an on-site instant-quote tool that adjusts by turnover and monthly transaction band.

bank feedsmobile appreceipt scanninginvoicing

QuickBooks

Cloud accounting from Intuit with heavy launch discounts. Sole Trader Plus files MTD Income Tax but not MTD VAT direct; Simple Start upward covers both.

From £12/moHMRC-recognised

QuickBooks Online is Intuit's cloud accounting product. The current UK line-up per quickbooks.intuit.com/uk/pricing (2026-09-30): Sole Trader Plus, Simple Start, Essentials, Plus and Advanced. All tiers are marked as MTD for Income Tax ready. A pricing-page footnote confirms Sole Trader Plus does NOT include direct MTD VAT submission or the VAT error checker; MTD VAT filing is available from Simple Start upward per Intuit's own MTD hub. A '90% off for six months' promo was live at audit; the promo and the 30-day free trial are mutually exclusive (the pricing page states you forfeit the trial if you take Buy Now). Exact GBP amounts are rendered client-side on the pricing page and could not be captured verbatim from a static fetch.

bank feedsmobile appreceipt scanninginvoicing

Xero

Widely used cloud accounting; UK tiers now Ignite / Grow / Comprehensive / Ultimate, Ignite (£18/mo) is the entry tier and includes MTD IT and MTD VAT.

From £18/moHMRC-recognised

Xero is the most widely used cloud accounting platform among UK accountants. Xero has renamed the UK tiers to Ignite, Grow, Comprehensive and Ultimate; the older Starter / Standard / Premium (and the previously discussed 'Simple' entry tier) no longer appear on the vendor's pricing page. Regular monthly prices per xero.com/uk/pricing-plans on 2026-09-30: Ignite £18, Grow £39, Comprehensive £55, Ultimate £70. A 90% off first 6 months promotion for new UK customers was live on the pricing page at audit; MTD IT and MTD VAT submission are stated as included from Ignite upward. 30-day free trial available; credit-card requirement is not explicitly stated. HMRC finder listing was not directly reachable in our audit (the finder is a JS-driven interactive tool).

bank feedsmobile appreceipt scanninginvoicing

Sage Accounting

Sage's cloud accounting product for VAT-registered sole traders, freelancers and small businesses; Start £20/mo + VAT regular (£2/mo for the first 6 months under Sage's current 90% off promo), Standard £43/mo + VAT, Plus £59/mo + VAT. Non-VAT sole traders should compare the separate Sage Sole Trader product (has a free tier).

From £20/moHMRC-recognised

Sage Accounting is Sage's cloud-only accounting product for VAT-registered sole traders, freelancers and small businesses. Payroll and essential HR are built in on Start upward; Sage Copilot (AI assistant) is included. Distinct from Sage 50 (desktop-rooted) and from Sage Sole Trader (a separate cloud product for non-VAT registered sole traders, with a free tier). Per sage.com pricing footnote captured via headless browser on 2026-09-30: 'Get 90% off for 6 months on Start, Standard, or Plus then £20, £43, or £59 per month (excluding VAT).' The 90% off first 6 months promo was live at audit.

bank feedsmobile appreceipt scanninginvoicing

At-a-glance comparison

CIS account options compared for MTD Income Tax, pricing as of 2026.

ProviderCIS deductionsMTD Income TaxCheapest tierFree route?
QuickBooksBuilt-in: auto CIS, contractor statements, CIS suffered reportYes, HMRC-recognisedFrom £12/mo (often discounted)No (free trial only)
FreeAgentYes, on all paid featuresYes, HMRC-recognised£19/mo paid, or £0 via NatWest/MettleYes, free with NatWest Group or Mettle account
XeroCIS deductions suffered on Ignite; contractor CIS300 filing needs the £5/mo CIS Contractor add-onYes, HMRC-recognisedIgnite £18/mo (subcontractors); Ignite + £5/mo CIS Contractor add-on for contractorsNo
Sage AccountingYes, full CIS moduleYes, HMRC-recognisedFrom £20/mo + VAT (90% off first 6 months at audit)No
CrunchYes, CIS bookkeeping handled by Crunch's accountantsYes, on Crunch Plus and aboveSoftware-only Crunch Plus £10 + VAT/mo; accountancy bundles from £27 + VAT/moFree plan exists (bookkeeping only, no MTD IT bundled)
QuickFile / PandleNo built-in CIS handling, manual tracking onlyYes, but MTD IT is paid on both: QuickFile via Power User subscription, Pandle via Pandle Pro (£5/mo + VAT)Free bookkeeping tier on both; paid step for MTD ITBookkeeping free; MTD Income Tax filing is paid on both

What you need to know

How CIS interacts with MTD for Income Tax

Under MTD for Income Tax, you submit quarterly updates of your gross self-employment income, that's the figure before CIS deductions. The 20% (or 30%) your contractor withheld doesn't reduce what you report; it sits as tax already paid against your annual bill. At the Final Declaration in January, HMRC nets the two off and you usually end up with a refund. So your software needs to track gross invoiced amounts and CIS deductions separately, not just net cash received. Tools that don't understand CIS will quietly understate your income (because they only see the net banked), that's the failure mode to avoid.

20% vs 30% CIS: what changes for your software

If you've registered as a subcontractor with HMRC, the contractor withholds 20%. If you haven't, they withhold 30%, the unregistered rate. Either way, the software treatment is identical: gross income is reported, the deducted amount is recorded as CIS suffered, and HMRC reconciles at the Final Declaration. There's no extra feature to look for, any CIS-aware tool handles both rates. If you're on 30%, register with HMRC's CIS scheme as soon as possible; the cashflow saving is immediate and you can usually do it online in a day.

Gross-payment status subcontractors

If you have gross-payment status (granted by HMRC after meeting business, turnover and compliance tests), contractors pay you in full without any CIS deduction. Your MTD reporting is simpler, you just report gross trading income quarterly, no CIS suffered to track. Most accounting tools (QuickBooks, FreeAgent, Xero, Sage) cope with this out of the box; you simply don't apply CIS deductions to invoices. Gross status doesn't exempt you from MTD itself, only from the deduction administration.

Comparing the CIS account options

QuickBooks is the strongest functional fit, automatic CIS deductions on invoices, contractor statement matching, and a CIS suffered report that maps directly to the figures HMRC wants. FreeAgent handles CIS just as completely and is free if you bank with NatWest Group or open a free Mettle account, which makes it the cheapest credible route. Sage Accounting has a full CIS module but its UI feels dated next to the others. Xero handles CIS on all current UK tiers: the entry Ignite tier (£18/mo regular) covers CIS deductions suffered by subcontractors (workable if you're on the receiving end of CIS), while contractors filing monthly CIS300 returns to HMRC need Ignite plus the £5/mo CIS Contractor add-on. Crunch is worth a look if you want CIS bookkeeping done for you by a real accountant.

The cheapest CIS-aware setup

If cost is the priority, FreeAgent via a free Mettle business account is the cheapest CIS-capable route, £0 with full CIS handling. Mettle is a free digital business account from NatWest Group, takes about ten minutes to open, and unlocks FreeAgent at no charge for as long as you make at least one transaction a month. Next cheapest for subcontractors: Xero Ignite at £18/mo regular (or £1.80/mo for the first 6 months under the promo live at audit), which handles CIS deductions suffered and MTD in one product. Contractors filing monthly CIS300 returns need Xero Ignite plus the £5/mo CIS Contractor add-on, or QuickBooks. QuickBooks is often discounted heavily in the first six months but jumps back after, and is usually the best functional fit for active subcontractors who don't qualify for free FreeAgent.

Claiming your CIS refund under MTD

Most CIS subcontractors are due a refund, you've had 20% withheld on gross income but your actual tax bill, after expenses and personal allowance, is lower. Under MTD nothing about the refund mechanism changes: HMRC reconciles your final position at the Final Declaration (due 31 January after the tax year). Your CIS-aware software produces a CIS suffered total which you (or your accountant) enter at Final Declaration; HMRC offsets it against your Income Tax and NICs liability and refunds the difference. Refunds usually arrive within 4–8 weeks of Final Declaration submission, but can be faster if your return is straightforward and you've nominated a bank account.

Can you stay on a spreadsheet?

Yes, and it's the cheapest route, but you'll be tracking CIS deductions manually in three columns (gross invoice, deduction, net received) on every job. Bridging software like 123 Sheets or My Tax Digital will submit the quarterly totals to HMRC, but doesn't understand CIS as a concept, it just reports the gross figure you've calculated. Workable if you have a handful of contractors and clean records; painful at any real volume. If you're invoicing more than a few jobs a month, the £12–£19 you'd pay QuickBooks or FreeAgent pays for itself in saved reconciliation time and reduces the risk of misreporting CIS suffered at year end.

CIS-only bookkeeping apps: when they make sense

Some subcontractors use CIS-specific apps that aren't full accounting platforms, they handle the deduction tracking and produce a year-end summary an accountant feeds into a Self Assessment. They're cheaper but don't submit MTD updates themselves, so you'd still need bridging software or accounting software on top. For most CIS subcontractors heading into MTD, picking one tool that does both (QuickBooks, FreeAgent, Sage) is simpler than chaining two. The exception is if you already have an accountant doing your year-end and want to keep your day-to-day app dead simple, in that case, a CIS-only app plus your accountant's MTD submission service can work.

Frequently asked questions

What's the best CIS account for MTD in 2026?+

QuickBooks is the strongest functional fit, built-in CIS deduction tracking, contractor statement matching, and full MTD Income Tax support in one product. FreeAgent is the cheapest credible option if you bank with NatWest Group or open a free Mettle business account, with the same CIS feature depth. Sage Accounting also handles CIS but feels dated. Xero Ignite (£18/mo regular) covers CIS deductions suffered for subcontractors; contractors filing monthly CIS returns need Ignite plus the £5/mo CIS Contractor add-on.

Is there a free CIS accounting account for MTD?+

FreeAgent is free if you hold a business current account with NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland, Ulster Bank or the free Mettle digital account, and it handles CIS properly. That's the only genuinely free CIS-aware MTD route.

What is the cheapest CIS software for subcontractors?+

Free, via FreeAgent + a free Mettle business account from NatWest Group. If that route doesn't suit, QuickBooks at around £12/mo (often discounted in the first months) is the next cheapest CIS-aware option. Xero's entry Ignite tier (£18/mo regular) handles CIS deductions suffered; contractors filing monthly CIS300 returns need a £5/mo CIS Contractor add-on. Sage Accounting starts higher (£20 + VAT/mo).

Do I need special CIS software for MTD?+

Not legally, MTD just requires digital records and quarterly submission, regardless of CIS. But CIS deductions are tedious to track manually, and software with built-in CIS handling will reconcile contractor statements, produce CIS suffered reports, and prevent reporting errors at year end. For active subcontractors, the £12–£19/mo for QuickBooks or FreeAgent typically pays for itself in saved bookkeeping time.

How does CIS work under MTD for Income Tax?+

You report your gross self-employment income quarterly, the figure before any CIS deductions. The 20% (or 30%) your contractor withheld is treated as tax already paid, and HMRC reconciles it at the Final Declaration in January. Most CIS subcontractors end up with a refund because they've effectively paid tax through the year and have allowable expenses to deduct.

Will I still get my CIS refund the same way under MTD?+

Yes. MTD changes how you keep records and how often you report income, not how CIS reconciliation works. Your CIS suffered total is offset against your Income Tax and NICs at Final Declaration (due 31 January after the tax year), and HMRC refunds the difference, typically within 4–8 weeks of submission.

What about 30% CIS deductions, does my software handle it differently?+

No. The software treatment is identical for 20% and 30% deductions, only the rate changes. If you're being deducted 30% it usually means you're not registered with HMRC as a CIS subcontractor. Registering moves you to 20%, which is a meaningful cashflow win and can be done online in around a day.

Do gross-status subcontractors need CIS software?+

No CIS-specific features are needed, contractors pay you in full and there are no deductions to track. You still need MTD-compliant software for quarterly Income Tax updates, but any HMRC-recognised tool (including the cheapest free options) is fine. You simply don't apply CIS deductions to invoices.

Can I use Xero's Ignite plan with CIS?+

Yes, if you're a subcontractor. Xero's Ignite tier (£18/mo regular) handles CIS deductions suffered, tracking what contractors have withheld from your invoices, which is exactly what you need for your Self Assessment and MTD Income Tax quarterly updates. Contractors (people paying subcontractors and filing monthly CIS300 returns to HMRC) need Ignite plus the £5/mo CIS Contractor add-on, which unlocks HMRC verification and monthly return filing from inside Xero.

Can I use a spreadsheet plus bridging software for CIS?+

Yes, and it's the cheapest route, but you'll be tracking CIS deductions manually in your spreadsheet (gross invoice, deduction, net received as separate columns). Bridging software like 123 Sheets or My Tax Digital will submit the totals to HMRC, but doesn't understand CIS as a concept. Workable for simple cases; painful at any volume.

Do I still file a Self Assessment under MTD if I'm a CIS subcontractor?+

Not in the old once-a-year form. MTD for Income Tax replaces it with four quarterly updates plus a Final Declaration. The Final Declaration plays the role of the old Self Assessment, it's where your CIS suffered, allowable expenses and any non-CIS income come together for HMRC to calculate the final liability and refund.

What if I have both CIS subcontractor income and other self-employment income?+

Report all self-employment income together in quarterly updates, CIS doesn't get a separate stream. The CIS suffered figure is the only CIS-specific number, and it's entered at Final Declaration. Software that supports CIS will let you tag invoices as CIS or non-CIS so the deductions only apply where they should.

Other situations