HMRC free MTD tool vs QuickFile
Answering the comparison people actually search for.
HMRC does not publish its own MTD for Income Tax filing software. It maintains the official list of tools approved to submit through its API, but the tools themselves are all third-party products.
So this isn't really a comparison, it's a choice between a product that exists (QuickFile) and something that doesn't. Below is what QuickFile actually offers.
QuickFile
QuickFile is a UK-built cloud accounting platform. The free XS tier is available for accounts with up to 200 nominal ledger entries per year (rolling 12 months); above that, paid ledger-volume tiers apply (£60 + VAT/year at the L tier of 1,001–4,000 entries). MTD VAT filing is available on the free tier. MTD Income Tax submission requires the paid Power User subscription from April 2026, per QuickFile staff on the community forum, after the free 2025-26 HMRC pilot ended. QuickFile's homepage separately states 'up to 1,000 nominal ledger entries free' which contradicts the pricing page's XS = up to 200 entries; where the two disagree, the pricing page is authoritative. The exact Power User price is not stated on the pricing page or the MTD product page as of 2026-09-30; community reports place it around £60/year + VAT, awaiting vendor confirmation.
What HMRC actually does
- •Publishes the recognised software list, every product approved to submit under MTD for Income Tax.
- •Publishes sign-up and eligibility guidance, thresholds, quarterly deadlines and how to enrol.
- •Grants digital exemptions in limited circumstances (age, disability, remoteness, incompatible religious beliefs).
- •Operates the API that every approved product submits through.
Other genuinely free approved options
Zoho Books has a genuinely free tier on HMRC's recognised list, no turnover cap, that covers MTD Income Tax and MTD VAT for sole traders and landlords. It is capped at 1,000 invoices and 1,000 expenses per tax year, one user plus one accountant, and no bank feeds; verified against HMRC's own recognised software finder and Zoho's UK pricing page. Our free MTD options page has the wider comparison across other approved products.
This URL exists as /compare/hmrc-free-tool-vs-quickfile/ because that's what people search for. There is no HMRC product to compare, only the honest answer to why one is expected.